An Interview with Solarstone by Pure Trance China Team 2 Years Ago (incl. question about TranceFix)

NameLessYet

Senior Member
Dec 1, 2024
661 Posts
1,095 Thanked
Two years ago, Pure Trance China was launched, after the Launch Extravaganza in Guangzhou, we did an one hour interview with Solarstone. During this two years, the video making of this interview faced many difficulties and was delayed for a long time. However, it's finally out today, many thanks to @Sean Cong for the hard working on the final video making. The interview includes 20 questions (including one about TranceFix haha), I did the first 30 minutes and @Lawn Jarre did the rest 30 minutes.

I also simply reorganize the content into text as an article here. Hope you like it too.

Video​


Question list​

My Part
Q1: What were the differences between the three performances in China between 2023 to 2024?
Q2: How is your new album progressing (outdated)?
Q3: What are your thoughts on Movement: One and Borderline, and what are the similarities and differences with the Pure Trance complications?
Q4: What are your thoughts on Uplifting producers transitioning to Tech Trance?
Q5: How do you think Trance (Raw / Deep / Hypnotic) is developing?
Q6: Have you heard of music forums like TranceFix, what do you think about them?
Q7: What are your thoughts on new Trance sounds like Will Atkinson and Ben Hemsley?
Q8: Do Trance producers have an advantage in producing ambient music?
Q9: What's your favorite genre besides Trance?

Lawn's Part
Q10: What are your thoughts on the electronic music pioneers?
Q11: What was the reason for the formation of Pure Breaks?
Q12: What do you think of the relationship between Trance and Breaks?
Q13: Why did you go to labels like Anjunabeats and Enhanced Progressive which we haven't been before?
Q14: How was last night's (two years ago) event?
Q15: In what sence do you prefer to perform?
Q16: When did you start noticing Chinese Trance listeners and producers?
Q17: For new producers, should they focus on commercial or "pure" sound?
Q18: To what extent do producers need to learn mixing in the early stages?
Q19: Is honing technique or musical understanding more important?
Q20: What are your requirements for the Remix competition (which hasn't been able to proceed for various reasons, but is definitely planned)?

Interview:

Some contents are removed for a better reading, so I suggest to watch the video.

My Part:

Q1: What were the differences between the three performances in China between 2023 to 2024?

Q: You have been to Guangdong for three times in the past year. Foshan, Guangzhou, and this time, Shenzhen. Are there any differences between these three?

A: Absolutely. One of the shows I did previously, I was like filling in for somebody else. The last show I did was where I met the guys who are now part of PURE TRANCE CHINA, including you. And this show we've just done was the first PURE TRANCE CHINA event, which was amazing. So, yeah, they were all very different. And this one was definitely my favourite.

Q2: How is your new album progressing (outdated)?

Q: It has been two years since your first release of your new album, how is your new album going?

A: Sovereign was the first track that I did, and that kind of set the theme for the album. And I kind of thought, okay, I'm on the way here. You know, I've recorded two other tracks, and they all had a kind of similar sort of epic vibe, and I thought I've got the sound for the album. And then I had a lot of personal stuff happen to me. I had a lot of mental problems, and I got married and had a baby, and everything was kind of like thrown off.

A: And it took me a while to get back in the studio, but I've recorded a lot of stuff since that I'm really happy with. And I've got two pieces left to record. I mean, Hope was meant to be on the album, but that's already come out as a single now, so I'm not sure whether to include it. But I think I've got two more tracks to finish, and then I've got enough. And I've also now got the title as well, finally, because I didn't have a title for four years, but now I have, but I'm not telling you what it is.

Q: So could you tell me something about the theme of the album?

A: It's a very personal record. There's a lot of the music on there. It's kind of about my feelings for my children. A lot for my son, Oscar, who's now 18. Because when I started recording this album, he wasn't even... Darcy, my second boy, wasn't even thought about. It's a very personal record, and I made all of this music at a time when things were quite tough for me personally, so it's a very personal record. It's not really a club record. It's more of a listening album.

Q: Is it emotional?

A: It's quite a deep record, and the lyrics are quite personal as well. So I'm not saying that my music isn't always emotional, but it's a lot more... it's a lot deeper.

Q3: What are your thoughts on Movement: One and Borderline, and what are the similarities and differences with the Pure Trance complications?

Q: Last year, Activa released Movement: One. It enjoys a great reputation among trance listeners. So how do you think of this compilation and his label Borderline?

A: I love it. I love it. I love Borderline. I love Rob. He's a really great guy, and he mixed Pure Trance 8 with me. Yeah, he's a really nice guy, and I love what he's doing with his labels. And I love the Movement compilation with the old-school kind of artwork. It's like Designers Republic type artwork. I think it's great. I really think he's doing something cool. It's kind of like he's got a very strong brand and a strong idea of what he wants, and it's different to what I do. And I think both together, it's really good for the trance scene. So yeah, I think he's great.

Q: I'm also a very great fan of Activa. So when we listen to the Movement and Pure Trance series, we often compare these two. So what do you think of the same and the difference between these two things?

A: I think, look, for me, Pure Trance was always about capturing the spirit of trance music and focusing on it as, you know, kind of like stepping away from the influences of house music and EDM and techno and all the rest of it and just keeping it Pure Trance. Rob's aim with his label is more to kind of recreate the sound.

Q: Classic Trance sound?

A: Recreating that sound of early 90s and 2000s trance, and that's quite different to what I do. I love it, don't get me wrong. I do like it and I do release some of that stuff on Pure Trance and I work with some of the same producers. But for me, it's slightly different. And I love what he does. I do love what he does, but it's not the same as what I do.

Q4: What are your thoughts on Uplifting producers transitioning to Tech Trance?

Q: Nowadays, it seems that some uplifting trance producers start to take tech trance. What do you think of this trend?

A: I'm not interested. It's not my kind of thing. I've never liked it. To me, it's just got no emotion to it. It's just hard and it's not what I play. I think it's part of the scene. I like all kinds of stuff. I think all kinds of stuff are good for the scene, but it's not my kind of thing at all.

Q: So will Pure Trance accept the submission of Tech Trance?

A: There's no point. It's not my kind of music. I don't want to sound negative, but I only sign stuff and release music that I will play in a set. That is the golden rule for me. If I really like it and I would play it, then I can sign it. But if it's not something I would play, I wouldn't sign it. I don't really think the Tech Trance is... I mean, I think it's quite boring.

Q: That is part of your radio show. “It's not kind of things we usually play, but we like it any way”.

A: That part of the show isn't really for anything trance-related. It's more for alternative kinds of stuff. It's more the kind of thing that I might listen to in the car. It's not the kind of thing I would play. But I wouldn't really listen to Tech Trance in the car. Although, having said that, there are some really good producers. I mean, I'm probably contradicting myself now, because Simon Patterson, John Askew, Mark Sherry, Sneijder @Sneijder, Bryan Kearney under his Karney alias. They do make some good stuff that I play. So, I'm kind of like... just full of shit, basically.

Q5: How do you think Trance (Raw / Deep / Hypnotic) is developing?

Q: Last year, we have talked about the Trance (Raw, Deep, Hypnotic). So, how do you think of their development?

A: I think it's amazing. I mean, it's really good for the scene. Before this genre was introduced, there was a lot of music in the progressive house and melodic techno, which didn't fit in there. And it didn't fit in the main trance genre either. And it was very, very hard for artists and labels to get their music heard because there was no platform for it. Whereas now, since the launch of this thing, it's fantastic because a lot of the music I release on my labels is what I consider raw, deep, hypnotic. And to me, it's my favourite kind. It's the real sort of stuff that really gets under your skin and takes you on a journey. And a lot of those tracks that were previously in the progressive house and melodic techno genres, which were kind of out of place, they have a home now. I love this chart. It's full of music on my labels and John 00 Fleming's label. It's just great. I think it's a good thing.

Q: Also Forescape Digital?

A: Yes, Forescape Digital. That's another good one Soluna, I love it. When I'm looking for music for my radio show, I don't really look in the trance main floor charts because I hate most of it. I think a lot of it is just crap. I look in the raw, deep, hypnotic genre. I look in the progressive house genre. I look in the organic house genre. Even in the techno. And I always listen to those, but I find going through the trance main floor, top 100 is just depressing because so much of it is just boring and it's old and it's been done before.

Q6: Have you heard of music forums like TranceFix, what do you think about them?

Q: Have you heard about the TranceFix forum? @Hensmon

A: Of course, man. It's been around for about 25 years.

Q: So your and activa’s label are highly regarded there. But it seems that they think that the current mainstream trance tracks are bad.

A: I don't like it either. I really respect the forums that are there, but I don't look at stuff on forums about myself or my labels because if you start as an artist, if you start looking at people's opinions of you and start basing what you do based upon people's opinions and what their reaction might be, you might as well give up. I release the music and make the music that I love and I hope that people love it too. But if you start going on forums, I mean, it's just the internet, isn't it? The internet is just full of people's opinions. Everyone's got their own opinion. What's the point in spending your time looking at other people's opinions? If you want to be yourself, you can't focus on other people. It's dangerous.

Q: However, there are many producers who grew up in the forums, like Julian Del Agranda @Julian Del Agranda, LostLegend @LostLegend and Avalon 62 @Jetflag. They are in Trancefix. I think it can be a good place to find good music.

A: I think that's great. Whatever suits you. I know, like Brendan, Factor B. I know that he always spends a lot of time on these forums because he's part of that scene, but I never was. When I started making music back in the early 90s, these things didn't exist. To me, it doesn't seem natural. Loads of people. I suppose to maybe the generation after me, it's kind of like sitting there with your friends and talking about stuff that you enjoy and comparing notes and stuff. But, I mean, would you want to read a page where they're talking about you and whether they like you and they don't and I think his latest release is shit and, well, I think it's good.

A: The thing about these forums is when you get to the end of the thread, they all just start blaming Tiësto anyway. They all just blame Tiësto for everything. They go, well, if Tiësto made Trance again, things would be okay. (well, something happens in 2026)

Q: Also blaming Armada.

A: I know, and it's not fair, everyone does their own thing. It's true about the Tiësto thing. I love Armin and I love Armada. I think that the Trance scene, anybody who is releasing music and making music and whose heart is in the right place, who is trying to do something good, I think it's great. There's no point in being negative about it and slagging people off. What's the point? You're wasting your energy. Life is hard enough anyway. If you can't say something nice, don't say anything. Spoken like a true father of two.

Q: Trance needs some commercial things to keep alive.

A: That's right. It can't all be underground and selling 10 copies. You need some artists and some shows like A State of Trance to push it to the mainstream. If one of my tracks gets played on A State of Trance, it makes such a difference to the recognition of the track. I played Revelation on my shows and I played it on the new single, I played it on A State of Trance. Everyone knows it now.

Q7: What are your thoughts on new Trance sounds like Will Atkinson and Ben Hemsley?

Q: It seems that there is another type of Trance that is rising, such as the tracks like Will Atkinson, Ben Hemsley, also Calvin Harris' Miracle, and Romy & Fred Again..’s Strong which got Grammy nominations. Do you think that they are Trance?

A: It's Eurodance. It never was Trance. All that stuff, like Castles in the Sky. It wasn't Trance music. It was Eurodance music. Very, very different things.

Q: However, Beatport signed them as Trance.

A: I know that, but that's up to them. What are they going to call it? Pop? Indie dance? It's not for me. I've got the key by Urban Cookie Collective. That's not Trance, is it? But that's what their music sounds like.

Q: How do you think of their relationship between them and the mainstream Trance? Because some Trance producers start making this, and even maybe Armin is trying to make that.

A: Well, that's up to them. That's fine if that's what they want to do. There is an appetite out there for this kind of thing because there's this 20, 25-year cycle that always happens with music. If you go back 10 years... Actually, is it a 30-year cycle? People were doing stuff that sounded like the 80s, and now people are doing stuff that sounds like the 90s. Because there's a new generation of people who weren't there first time round. The people who are listening to this kind of reinvented 90s music, they're not the same people who listened to it first time round.

A: I had an email from somebody today, an artist, who said to me that "I really love your new single, Revelation, and I would really like to make a 90s-style old-school Trance remix of it." This guy's great, but I was like, what's the point of that? To me, this is when I was making Trance in the 90s. I don't really want somebody to make a track that sounds like me 30 years ago.

Q8: Do Trance producers have an advantage in producing ambient music?

Q: Some Trance producers like Ferry Corsten under his alias Ferr and Above & Beyond, have tried ambient making. Do you think the Trance producers have an advantage in creating ambient?

A: I do, I love it. I did it myself back in 2000 era. I went through a period of making a lot of ambient music, like after-hours mixes, they were called. I love this kind of things. If you have a good Trance record and you remove all the drums and the bass lines and everything, and just make it all about the pads, I love that. There was a series of albums, the Chilled Out Euphoria albums. There was Red Jerry did the first Chilled Euphoria, and then he did Deep and Chilled Euphoria, both of which featured tracks from me, and then me and my old partner Andy did the third one, which was called Chilled Out Euphoria, and I loved all that. And there's producers doing it again now, and I think it's great. There's an audience for it.

Q: Some of your first album tracks were in that.

A: Yeah. I still make Chilled Out stuff, but I don't really like going backwards. I love other people's music. When I make music, I want to do something new, but I haven't necessarily. Although some people listening to this will probably be like all your music sounds the same, and that's fine.

Q: So will Pure Trance labels, like Electronic Architecture, release an ambient album in the future?

A: Well, if you remember, I did Electronic Architecture 2 into an ambient edition. It was digital, and then I think we did like 200 in a specially printed cardboard sleeve, which I really enjoyed doing. I asked the artists to make me 100 BPM ambient versions of their tracks, and I loved doing that. I think it would be nice to do another ambient album.

A: People say to me, will there be an Electronic Architecture 5? Somebody asked me that yesterday. Well I need to do the new Solarstone album? I've got another thing that I'm working on, and these compilations take me months to do, and there will be an Electronic Architecture 5, but whether it's next year or the year after, I don't know. And an ambient album? I don't know. We'll see.

A: I think it would be really great when artists make a track, and they make an ambient version as well. I know John O'Callaghanhas been asking artists to make a chill-out version of their track, because he's got really into yoga and meditation. I think that's great. What I don't want to do is ask our artists to spend a lot of time producing something that isn't going to sell and isn't going to make them any money. You can't take the piss with artists. I'm not going to say you have to make an ambient mix. That would be unfair. But if they want to then it will be great. That Magdalena @Magdelayna guy, he does these really great chilled-out tracks in the style of chill-out euphoria, he did a remix of Feeling This Way which is really good. Funny, he also did one of my tracks, Seven Cities a few years ago, but I didn't like it. Funny, though, because he's such a great producer. (haha)

Q9: What's your favorite genre besides Trance?

Q: Besides trance, what is your favourite music genre? And how does it influence you?

A: Outside of trance, I don't have a favourite genre at all. I like loads of stuff. I like pop music, classical music, my son plays a lot of dark metal in the car and I like some of that. My favourite album last year was an album called Alluvium by an artist called C Duncan, which was just beautiful. I got the new Pet Shop Boys album the other day. Have you heard of them?

Q: No, unfortunately.

A: You're so young! The Pet Shop Boys, they're one of the greatest synth pop bands ever. They've been around for 40 years. You must have heard West End Girls. I love all kinds of stuff. I still buy vinyl, but I don't buy dance music vinyl. I buy just albums I want to listen to. My wife and I started doing this thing recently where the first thing we do in the morning is we go into the lounge, choose a vinyl record, put it on with the baby, drink a coffee while listening to an album. That's our morning ritual.

Q: That's interesting to listen to the ambient music on the speakers rather the earphone. It becomes the part of the environment.

A: Yeah, well, you sound like Brian Eno now. Brian Eno said that as well.

Lawn's Part

Q10: What are your thoughts on the electronic music pioneers?

Q: Speaking of Brian Eno, I’ll really want to know your opinions about pioneers of electronic music like Kraftwerk, Tangerine Dream or Jean-Michel Jarre.

A: I love all that stuff. When I was a kid, my mother's husband, Andrew, he was a big Jarre fan, so he would play a lot of Jean-Michel Jarre. He still loves him now, actually. He was very happy when I did a remix of Oxygen a few years ago. And I love Tangerine Dream, I love Kraftwerk. I play Kraftwerk in my set sometimes. I've sampled quite a lot of Tangerine Dream. Who else was there, early innovators?

Q: Klaus Schulze?

A: Yeah and Depeche Mode. But my biggest influences were, they weren't electronic music. It was like Trevor Horn, he's a legendary producer. He produced The Art Of Noise, Frankie Goes to Hollywood, lots of really great stuff in the 80s which he used. He was one of the first big producers to start using like sampling technology and sequences. And that stuff was very big with me in my teenage so he was quite influential with me. And also a producer called Jeff Lynne who was the guy behind Electric Light Orchestra. My mom played him a lot when I was a kid and his productions were very cleverly mixed and engineered. And he mixed together live instruments with electronic sounds. And his keyboard player is a guy called Richard Tandy. And I'm quite a big fan of him as well.

Q: So do you think that pioneer electronic music are better than electronic dance music?

A: No, I don't. I like all kinds of music. You know I've got a lot of respect for the people who did it first, but if I'd been around then, I would have done it first as well. So, It's about when you were born a lot of it, isn't it? It's kind of a bit like plucking the fruit from the lowest branches. When something hasn't been done before and people start doing it, they kind of tend to be more successful because it's a new thing and other people haven't done it. When you're trying to follow in the footsteps of something that was done 40 years ago, you can't. All the chords and melodies have already been used. It's a lot harder. So I think if I'd been born in the 60s and I'd been making music in the 80s, I would probably have beenone of the pioneers of that because I know what I would have done.

Q: And do you think it is harder to produce music in these times than before?

A: No, that's the thing. It's much easier to produce something very, very average. It's very easy these days to make electronic music because there are templates and sound banks and horrible MIDI apps that I hate. It's very easy to just drag and drop and think you've made a piece of music. That doesn't make you a musician. It's like painting by numbers. If I want a sound for one of my tracks, I'll usually create the sound. I know what I want it to do. When I use a synth or something, I'm not just going to "oh, I want a riser or a down lifter". I hate all of that stuff. I hate it when I sign a track and then I sign another track and I hear the same samples in it. It's so lazy and splice. Where's the creativity? Where's the originality? Where's the hunger to make something new? People are like, oh, I need some drums. I'm just taking off splice. Oh I need a effect going up, I'll just take one from the sample pack. Why not use the knobs on your synths and create it, spend an hour making a sound.

Q: I believe music comes from the heart.

A: I agree, and if you have an idea in your head, I really want it to do this, then create it. You have all of these tools, you know, there's so many soft synths available, hundreds and hundreds and hundreds, there's so many tools there to make your own sounds. Why not just take a sound that somebody else has made? I think it's destroying our music scen, when I get sent these tracks by artists who've just dragged and dropped, I just think it's horrible. I wish they'd stop sending me them.

Q11: What was the reason for the formation of Pure Breaks?

Q: Pure Trance has a sub-label called Pure Breaks, that has many releases, why do you start this sub-label?

A: Because I love the sound of trance and breaks, always have loved that sound, even going back to like Banco de Gaia, Rabbit in the Moon, artists like Future Sound of London, I've always loved that sound of Orbital. I love those bands, and they use a lot of break beats and mix it with kind of like trance melodies. Like Sam Laxton, he made this really brilliant remix of a track on one of my labels, he just wanted to combine breaks with the melodies. So he just did this on spec and sent it to me. I love this sound and I want to try and do something to kind of bring this back a bit, so that's why I set up the label. Sam did the remix of The Last Defeat as well, and there's also that Alucard track, Midway. And I just kind of opened it up and said to people, you know, if you want to do this kind of thing, here is a platform for it, and the artwork is really cool as well, with like Pure Trance sprayed onto bricks, it's wicked, so it's a label I'm really kind of excited about.

Q12: What do you think of the relationship between Trance and Breaks?

Q: You recently collaborated with Darren Tate and that's a breaks version of your classic The Last Defeat Part 2. So what's your opinion on the relationship between trance, and especially classic trance and breaks?

A: I love it, yeah. I just think it works, man. As long as you know what you're doing, because breaks should make you want to dance, and if you don't understand the way breaks work in a club, then you don't want to do it. It should really make you want to move. If it's too jagged and stiff, it doesn't really work. If you just take a trance kick and trance snare, and instead of going "dun-t", you make it go "dun-t, dun-t, dun-t", it doesn't really work. It needs to have a shuffle. It needs to have funk, a little bit of funk.

Q: So that's how A Long Way From Home works, right?

A: Well, Darren understands what he's doing, and when we worked on that track, kind of like the Timeless Mix I did. So I sent him ideas for what we call the Timeless Mix, which was kind of like the original version that we had. And then he started making this breaks version, and then he came up with some new sounds. So I included some of his sounds into this version, and he included my sounds into that. So we ended up with two mixes where he was more, I would say he was like 80% responsible for the break beat version, and I was kind of 80% responsible for the Timeless Mix. And we used like 20% of each one in each one. I really liked the fact that it was like the first ever Solarstone single, The Calling, that had two mixes. One was breaks, and one was 4-4. And I really liked the idea of revisiting that kind of idea, that package, I might do it again.

Q13: Why did you go to labels like Anjunabeats and Enhanced Progressive which we haven't been before?

Q: Speaking of A Long Way From Home, this was your first release in Anjunabeats. And this year, you also have your first release on Enhanced Progressive with Farius. Can you share something about how these collaborations came out? Why you decided to release on these labels you haven't been before?

A: It's just about the music. Me and Darren, we did a show in London a few years ago. I went back to his house. and he took me down to his studio and we said let's make a track. And then he sent me some chords. I came up with the idea for the vocal and some bits and we just did it. And Darren is very involved with Anjuna. It just made sense to release it there.

A: For the other one with Farius, I saw him at gigs like Dreamstate a few years ago. Every time I saw him, he would say, when are you going to do something for Enhanced? When he asked me this again, and I said, well, why don't we do a track together? Because I thought it would be unusual and interesting, our styles are so different. I sent him a little melody of just like a piano thing with some drums. Then he messed around with it and sent me back. On his demo, he had this really cool bit in the end. And I thought, that's really different and would be really interesting. So I carried on working on it on a bit and sent it back to him.When he sent me his next version, it didn't have the bit at the end. He'd taken it out. And I was like, where's that bit from the end? He said, oh, I didn't really think you liked it. I was like, that's my favourite part. So he put it back in.

A: And that's how we ended up with this really great track, which is kind of like Solarstone, Solarstone, Solarstone, and Farius, Farius. Farius. Farius, Solarstone. And then in terms of releasing it, it just made sense to do it on Enhanced Progressive, because they were doing this compilation album. I love playing that track out, it was massive at a state of trance. And I played it last night, too. And it just sounded great, they love it. Because it's like, it's kind of like what I do, but a little bit different.

To be continue..

 
Last edited:

NameLessYet

Senior Member
Dec 1, 2024
661 Posts
1,095 Thanked

Continue


Q14: How was last night's (two years ago) event?

Q: So how do you feel about last night's Pure Trance China Launch Extravaganza?

A: Oh, it was just amazing. I'll tell you what it really reminded me of. When we first started doing Pure Trance parties, when it was really new and it was new for the fans and it was exciting for them. It had that same kind of like raw energy and the enthusiasm and excitement about it. And I also love the fact that the people there were so young as well. Like introducing this to a new generation of trance fans. It really was great. It really made me happy. This is just the beginning and we've got a lot more planned. The crew, the people, everybody who's involved has just been so great.

Q15: In what sence do you prefer to perform?

Q: For these performances, where do you prefer to have your performance? Indoor or outdoor?

A: Oh, that's a funny one because it depends. I mean, I don't mind the big festivals, they're quite good in one way.

Q: Like Luminosity?

A: No, I don't mean that. I mean like the massive festivals that you sometimes play. Those big massive ones where you've got like 15,000 or 20,000 people and there's loads of DJs and you only play for an hour. They're okay. Luminosity obviously is a special case. Luminosity is quite small, intimate thing, but it's outside, when the weather is good, Luminosity is the best. And I'm playing there this year as well on a Sunday, for me, like that is amazing.

A: Generally, I prefer like a small club with like, I don't know, between 200 and 500 people. That for me is the best kind of party because it's like you're right there with the people and it's intimate and everyone feels like they're a part of a family. And if you've got like a really good booth and a really good sound system and everyone's packed into this room, that to me is what it's all about.

A: It's not about the main stage and fireworks and massive screens. To me, if you have to have fireworks and massive screen to make it good, it means the music's not good enough. It's more like a pop festival, isn't it? You get stuff like the Afterlife thing where you have this massive screen and everyone's like, wow. I'm not sure many people come away from those events saying, did you like that track or did you like that track? They probably can't remember which tracks were played because they all kind of sound the same.

Q: But trance would still be trance without fireworks, right?

A: Yeah, with a trance, in a trance club, you can have like 200 people in the room and just like a strobe and some smoke and no screen and you still have a really good time. I've done parties like that where it's just been really basic and sometimes they're the best because everyone's not distracted. No phones, you know, no one's got their phone out. Everyone's just like heads down. That's the best kind of night, I think.

Q16: When did you start noticing Chinese Trance listeners and producers?

Q: Besides party, another mission of Pure Trance China is helping releasing trance music from China. When did you first notice the trance audience or producers in China?

A: The whole thing came about when I was in China about six months ago. I was talking to Nova, who's one of the founders of Invaders Music. And we were just talking about China and to the trance in China and I said wouldn't it be really interesting to do something here? And he was saying to me about how there's a lot of young trance producers over here, really enthusiastic and there's a lot of interest in the music. And I just thought it would be interesting.

A: Before this, I hadn't really received many demos or anything from Chinese trance producers, they just didn't come in. I really wasn't aware of it, and so we did this call out on the Chinese social media for Chinese producers start sending in tracks. And so there's been some really good stuffs. So the whole Pure Trance China thing, it's about encouraging and releasing music from young Chinese and older Chinese producers, doing events and just pushing the sound over here and trying to give them a bit of a platform.

A: I know it's very difficult in China. I've had some conversations with people last night where they were saying it's very hard to get labels to listen to the tracks because they say that there's a lot of preconceptions about it. A guy was telling me last night about he just didn't get any reply from a lot of labels. And he thought it was something to do with the fact that he's from China. I don't understand how that's possible. But for me, it's just about the music. If the music is good, it doesn't really matter where it's from.I think that this enthusiasm from the Chinese producer world is fantastic and I'd like to be involved in it.

Q17: For new producers, should they focus on commercial or "pure" sound?

Q: China has many passionate trance producers, but they are just starting to gain international recognition. For their development, do you think their production direction, should focus on commercialization or purity?

A: I think if they want to send me their tracks, then they know how the labels work, right? There's Pure Progressive, Pure Trance, and Pure Trance NEON, and Pure Breaks. If they're fans of the labels, they know the kind of music I like. If they want to release on the labels and they've made a piece of music they think works, then send it over. It's like the same anywhere. I'm not dictating to anybody for what they should do. But if they like what I do, and that's the kind of stuff they want to make, then do it, send it over and I'll listen to it, if it's good, I'll release it. That's simple.

Q: Is there anything you want to tell to the starters?

A: I would say create your own sounds. Create tracks from the start, don't use templates, don't use sample pack, don't use midi packs. Just do something, spend time, learn your craft, learn how to do these things, learn about programming drums, learn about melodies and writing melodies. Start with a strong melody and don't think there's any shortcut to this, you have to spend time learning how this works. If you just want to do it in a day, don't bother, there's enough crack music in the world already. For me, it's really personal. Because I've spent 30 years of my life doing this. I think it should be personal to them as well.

Q18: To what extent do producers need to learn mixing in the early stages?

Q: Well, can a bad mixing or mastering prevent a track from becoming an excellent one?

A: I mean, mixing is an art in itself. Mixing is difficult and I'm not great at mixing. I can do it, but I would rather let somebody else... Sometimes let somebody else do the final mix. I work with several great mastering engineers. I sometimes will do a stem mix, which we discussed the other day. You send the individual layers, and then they will do the final mix. Because it's about blending EQ, and stereo placement, and filtering. Sometimes a really good mixing and mastering engineer can hear something in your track that you don't really notice because you're too close to it. Sometimes they can bring something out.

A: As an example. A track from my blue album called This Is Where It Starts with Jonathan. I just couldn't get that right and there was something wrong with it. So I found this guy called Cass at Wired Masters in London. I sent him the track and when he sent it to me back, he'd just done these subtle things, he monoed some sounds, and placed them somewhere in the mix. And he'd really made the drums pop, turned some sounds down.. And he'd just done these things in mixing things that I hadn't done myself. Because when you're composing and you're producing, sometimes you've been working on the track for three weeks. And then you get to the mixing stage with your ears are tired, and you're a bit fed up. You need a break.

A: So I think that you don't have to be able to compose, produce, mix, and master, engineer your tracks. Because those are traditionally jobs done by different people. Like a producer's role has changed a lot. If you say, I'm a producer of music, that often means that you write it, compose it, produce it, mix it, master it yourself. You don't have to.

A: You can do a really good demo, and then get involved with an engineer,and a mastering guy, and a mixing guy, these things cost money. A lot of labels release a lot of crack music because they don't invest any money. They just get sent a track then put it out. And the artists haven't invested anything either. If you want your music to sound as good as possible, then pay the right people to get somebody to engineer it, get somebody to mix it, get somebody to master it. Find a professional label who will spend time on doing interesting social media post and they will send it to the right DJs.This isn't all free. Just because artists can download free software, and you have to invest in your own career.

Q: Then how much should Chinese trance producers learn about mixing and mixing in the early stages, because they're just starting.

A: Well, they need to learn about composing and finding sounds and making music. Mixing and mastering is not making music. That's fine tuning at the end. You need to have a good melody. You need to learn how to play an instrument, learn how to play the keyboard. You know, just draw notes in with a mouse, you need to learn your craft. There's no shortcuts here.

Q: Know how to compose music by oneself is more important.

A: Yeah, learn how to make a melody that's catchy, a hook. And if you're making like progressive house or something, you need to learn about rhythm and arrangement and filtering and creating a groove. You need to learn about what makes people move. It's not just a case of downloading something and putting it in and going, there, I've made a track. If you were painting a picture, you wouldn't get somebody else's picture and change it a bit, would you? You should learn how to paint it.


Q19: Is honing technique or musical understanding more important?

Q: What do you think is more important for producing a good trance track? Harming music production skills or enhancing music insights?

A: Oh god, that's a good one, I don't know, man. Whatever works for you, you need to have your own production skills. If you haven't got a good melody in the first place, or trying to tell a story or something, trying to convey an emotion, or you come up with an idea and it makes you really happy, get goosebumps on your arms, then you've got something good. So, production is like the second thing you do, in my opinion.

Q: The melody's inspiration comes from the experiences, right?

A: I don't know, actually.
Because I know a lot of other producing people, they say, oh, I just put some drums in and then it inspired me to do this, and then I accidentally did this. Some people create music like that. I can only tell you my opinion.

Q20: What are your requirements for the Remix competition (which hasn't been able to proceed for various reasons, but is definitely planned)?

Q: Pure Trance China has announced the remix competition, do you have any requirements or expectations for this submission?

A: I don't have any expectations at all. I did a remix competition the last time. It was like 2002 of Naked Angel, and I had like over 100 entries and I ended up hating the record as I heard that 100 times. So I want them to respect the original melodies and don't change those. And I want them to I want them to take the key elements of the original and keep them the same and then put a bit of themselves into the tracks to make the rest about them.

Q: What kind of tracks do you think is worth remixing?

A: I haven't decided yet. There's going to be at least three tracks from three different artists on the label. But I need to speak to those artists first. I know that they're going to want to do it because it would be fun. I just want people to do something that if they listen to that track and they think that track really inspires them and thet love to do a version like this, then do it. What I don't want them to do is download a template and then put the beats in and go, oh, I've made a remix. Those ones will be just deleted.

Q: Do you prefer instrumental trance or vocal trance?

A: I'm not really a big fan of vocals. It's not that I don't like vocal tracks, but I don't hear many trance tracks whose vocals usually mean nothing in the lyrics. It's just like somebody singing about flying high. Quite often they're quite insipid and kind of cheesy. I don't like that. Take Clare Stagg for example, who I worked with on the Pure album, her lyrics are brilliant. I've done a track with a female vocalist for my new album and the lyrics kind of really mean something,

A: But I'm not going to have a vocal track for the remix competition. And the simple reason for that is working with vocals takes a lot of skill and experience. And a lot of producers still can't do it. I wouldn't expect a new talent or an amateur to be able to do that. If we get remixes through where the music is okay, but the vocals sound shit, it's wasting everybody's time. So I think it's going to be instrumental stuff.

Q: So the goal of the remix competition is to find some talent one.

A: Yes, exactly. If you're doing a remix, then a lot of the hard work has already been done for you. Some of my favourite remixes of my tracks were remixes. Take the V-One remix of Seven Cities, Airwave he had made a track called Dead Cities which we love. And Jerry from Hooj, Red Jerry, he just said to him, take your Dead Cities track and put the Seven Cities guitar over the top and then change the notes to go with Seven Cities. And he did it in like four hours, that to me was a bloody good remix.

A: What you want from a remix is you want another producer to give you your song in their style. You don't want them to create something completely new. If I asked Orkidea to do a remix of one of my tracks,what I want is just to just take an Orkidea track, because he has his own sound, take out his bits, put my bits in and there it is.

Q: Just like using the author's idea in another ways.

A: That's right. So if you already have your own sound that sounds like you and nobody else, then you take it and do a remix. You can put somebody else's parts in there and then that's what a remix is, in my opinion.
 

Progrez

Legendary Member
Jun 17, 2022
3,927 Posts
2,265 Thanked
Maybe it's something we should take a lesson if you don't have anything nice to say don't say anything but how can you pass constructive criticism though?

My criticism is not because I am trying to run a popularity contest. I honestly do really care about the genre.
 
Last edited:

Pokkryshkin

Senior Member
May 7, 2022
738 Posts
538 Thanked
There’s nothing wrong with listeners expressing their opinions and sharing their emotions. However, Rich is right that creators shouldn’t pay too much attention to comments. Ultimately, music is primarily made for self expression, to convey one’s feelings and inner world. If a creator starts adapting to audience tastes, their music ceases to be genuine and personal, becoming something commissioned rather than a reflection of the artist’s true self.
 

Jetflag

Legendary Member
Jul 17, 2020
4,584 Posts
3,968 Thanked
Thorough interview, and thanks for plugging trancefix chaps 🙏

question: would it be an idea to also publish this interview in video format on say: YouTube for bigger reach?

or is that going to get people into trouble?
 
  • Thanks
Reactions: NameLessYet

NameLessYet

Senior Member
Dec 1, 2024
661 Posts
1,095 Thanked
Thorough interview, and thanks for plugging trancefix chaps 🙏
Actually, I was not a TranceFixer at that time (2024.5.4). I went on to TranceFix maybe once a week and saw it as a place full of criticism, but it was the yearly rankings and TF.R that made it different. Now, this forum is also a good place to find those non-ASOT-will-played trance or underground stuffs, and share the good things I found, although I still like to watch the criticism.

question: would it be an idea to also publish this interview in video format on say: YouTube for bigger reach?

or is that going to get people into trouble?
Maybe we will publish, @Lawn Jarre says that we have a YouTube channel, and we used to have an Instagram but it was banned for some unknown reason.
 
Last edited:
  • Thanks
Reactions: Jetflag