this track is from 2007 you can consider "the real producers stopped to do proper stuff" at this time, so not really much good competition. i mean "the pretenders" are just low skill school kids ofc they won't do really good stuff. guys like JXL moved long ago.
Since those producers quit trance, they're no longer relevant to this discussion, and there is little point in bringing them up. This is about Blueman and what he contributed to the genre with Nyctalopia. The concept wasn't entirely new - after all, a lot of anthem trance used orchestral/classical samples, and the Black Hole guys had already made a precursor to Blueman's style.
What makes Andy Blueman stand out is that
he reigned this specific style and many of his 2007-~2010 productions became classics of the genre, even if the competition was not as stiff as in the golden era. His ideas built up on previous work, but his
execution was fresh, which is what gets lost in the discussion.
As
@Gagi correctly pointed out, this sub-genre was not going to last long. The long, orchestral breakdowns are not dance-able, and you can only play so many of these in a radio or DJ set. That's one of the reasons it "works bad", in your own words. Even then, I still give props to Blueman for this direction in uplifting trance.