Sin3waves- Prog House/Trance composition feedback request

Bobby Summa

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 7, 2022
Messages
340
Thanked
236
Age
46
Location
Brighton UK
Website
soundcloud.app.goo.gl


OK
So. Ive just altered some things and am fairly pleased. Taken peoples suggestions but had to change the key of the track a little. -1.

The volume of some parts is out but if i can know if the vibe is good or if any single sounds etc ( hand clap too sharp?).

Anyhow. Done about 10 hours this weekend on it. Ive only recorded 3/4 minutes as need to alter key changes of rest ( transpose slightly trickier than you may think - to a tired soul lol)

@Hensmon @Gagi id appreciate if you heard it. Volumes out but not a hard fix.

Cheers.
 
  • Thanks
Reactions: Hensmon

Hensmon

Admin
TranceFix Crew
Joined
Jun 27, 2020
Messages
2,477
Thanked
1,925
Location
USA
Yo, thanks for posting.

I think this entire time you've had as good track idea, with very nice sounds, you just needed to structure/arrange it in a more familiar way over a 6-8 minute timeframe. I think you are still struggling with that. The new long intro you introduced is not as good as the previous one imo, feels out of place and not connected with the main track idea.

Take what you already had and create an arrangement that allows it to build and come together, imo you don't really need to create different parts or more ideas, just use the elements and theme of what exists already and use them to create proper track sections that allow for breakdowns, build, intro and outro etc.

Even if you have to start with something basic; like Intro, build(up), breakdown/peak, build(down), outro then thats a good structure foundation to grow from. In the previous track I think you already had a nice intro and build up of your elements down, but then were missing a clear middle section like a breakdown to be expressive or atmospheric that leads to the coming together and eventually build-down/deconstruction into an outro. Your outro in these previous tracks is also kind of done as well actually.
 

Gagi

Archon
TranceFix Crew
Joined
Jun 27, 2020
Messages
3,034
Thanked
2,175
Location
Serbia
Have to say I quite agree with Hens here. You clearly have some good ideas, but for me right now it's all about having some consistency within the track. Structure and arrangement first, I am not sure if you need to add more new ideas to the track.
 
  • Thanks
Reactions: Bobby Summa

Bobby Summa

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 7, 2022
Messages
340
Thanked
236
Age
46
Location
Brighton UK
Website
soundcloud.app.goo.gl
Yo, thanks for posting.

I think this entire time you've had as good track idea, with very nice sounds, you just needed to structure/arrange it in a more familiar way over a 6-8 minute timeframe. I think you are still struggling with that. The new long intro you introduced is not as good as the previous one imo, feels out of place and not connected with the main track idea.

Take what you already had and create an arrangement that allows it to build and come together, imo you don't really need to create different parts or more ideas, just use the elements and theme of what exists already and use them to create proper track sections that allow for breakdowns, build, intro and outro etc.

Even if you have to start with something basic; like Intro, build(up), breakdown/peak, build(down), outro then thats a good structure foundation to grow from. In the previous track I think you already had a nice intro and build up of your elements down, but then were missing a clear middle section like a breakdown to be expressive or atmospheric that leads to the coming together and eventually build-down/deconstruction into an outro. Your outro in these previous tracks is also kind of done as well actually.
No worries il go back to the original and use this intro for a more cinematic or atmospheric ambient track.
cheers.

il try a propper arrangement soon
 
  • Thanks
Reactions: Hensmon

Bobby Summa

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 7, 2022
Messages
340
Thanked
236
Age
46
Location
Brighton UK
Website
soundcloud.app.goo.gl
Update (private soundcloud link… just thought id see what it looks like with trancefix presents etc, - no one else can see it)
https://soundcloud.com/robert-george-969154201%2Fsin3wave-tr-fix-vers-219-at%2Fs-1wPW44WxS8X

@Magdelayna
@Hensmon @Gagi @jetflag @LostLegend @Recharge Hope you guys dont mind me tagging you. Just wondered what you thought of this . Its still not finished but i feel its getthere finnaly. I couldn’t get the original intro from other version to sound right ( apologies) but what you think of this intro and general development. I know some of the sound positioning isnt quite there yet, may move melody and elements in the intro

Things i may change.
Tempo feels a bit quick. But its 129bpm.

Il deffo do a better arrangement, this is just a rough one. The track will have longer mid section.

Lite drops or whatever those things are called that signify when the kick will come in or dissapear.

il add a bit more percussion. Thinking of having a bit more of a standard hand clap to go along with the one thats there. This one will have less reverb and be lower pitched that the one thats there.

I know @Hensmon you loved the intro i did before but I genuinely couldn’t get it to match, the pitch made it sound like it was a different song. I can use it for another track though.

Hope you guys like whats there. Many thanks

Rob. (Bobby Summa)
 
Last edited:

Gagi

Archon
TranceFix Crew
Joined
Jun 27, 2020
Messages
3,034
Thanked
2,175
Location
Serbia
I think you have enough good ideas to turn this into a longer track with a proper structure.
 
  • Thanks
Reactions: Bobby Summa

Hensmon

Admin
TranceFix Crew
Joined
Jun 27, 2020
Messages
2,477
Thanked
1,925
Location
USA
Yo Bobby sorry for the slow response, been busy as fuck.

I think this latest version is an improvement and you are heading in the right direction. Tell you what. let's see if any of the other folks here pitch in, then we can take it to personal messages to see if we can finalize the arrangement (which still needs work). But you are definitely getting there and think you will have a good track once those arrangement fixes are made.
 
  • Thanks
Reactions: Bobby Summa

Bobby Summa

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 7, 2022
Messages
340
Thanked
236
Age
46
Location
Brighton UK
Website
soundcloud.app.goo.gl
Yo Bobby sorry for the slow response, been busy as fuck.

I think this latest version is an improvement and you are heading in the right direction. Tell you what. let's see if any of the other folks here pitch in, then we can take it to personal messages to see if we can finalize the arrangement (which still needs work). But you are definitely getting there and think you will have a good track once those arrangement fixes are made.
Hi Hensmon. No worries man. I can see you and Gagi have been very busy. Cant wait till Nov 1st!
Thanks for the feedback from you and Gagi also. I actually did more on the track in the last few days, mainly refining the intro. Its theme is same as the last version on here but i have changed one or two effects ( which add quite abit to the atmosphere). I also have added a little bit of female chanting. (from a sample pack i bought ).
i have tried to ensure the intro doesn’t sound muddy and cluttered also.

If im honest im very excited about how its sounding. I am not at work today so plan to ‘dive in’ to the track. Will post later after ive done work on it
 

Bobby Summa

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 7, 2022
Messages
340
Thanked
236
Age
46
Location
Brighton UK
Website
soundcloud.app.goo.gl
Apologies for big post /text.

I put something together, but definitely not perfect by quite a bit.
Acid line crowds the mix where it is. I will see what its like if i bring in the lead in where the acid comes in then perhaps use an edited version of the acid line when the lead melody ends.
I like the intro how it is though. Perhaps it could be better but it isn’t bad.
May change the kick or louden it. Not sure about the clap i added. May scrap that and try either different clap or edited version or an open hi hat
Didnt get much change to work on the arrangement but am forming ideas as i type this.
Still pretty sure i can get a good track outa this.

sorry to tag and bug you guys. Don’t worry if you’re too busy.

incidentally along with this tune ive been making another trance tune. Its floaty but 144 bpm interestingly and has an orbital chime like lead sound in it .
Also seeing a mate sunday to collaborate on a tune for our first ever collaboration. Hes a great musician.
Might start a trance track also. @Hensmon @Gagi . If you have any preference for any possible releases in terms of style, we could attempt a track in that vein. If its good enough then you are free to release it. Hes a great guy and musician so here’s hoping we can get something good done. Then its up to you if its releasable. We wont be offended if it isnt. But i think good things will be cooking on Sunday! Roast Trance me thinks! ( hey great name for a track ???)
@Hensmon
@Gagi @LostLegend @jetflag @Recharge @IXM @Magdelayna

 
Last edited:

Bobby Summa

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 7, 2022
Messages
340
Thanked
236
Age
46
Location
Brighton UK
Website
soundcloud.app.goo.gl
Latest alteration.

Havent been happy with any of the intros ive made. Ive just wanted to do a lot better. Apologies for trying so many.

ive actually created the atmosphere i wanted on this intro, I’ve actually not made an atmosphere like it before.

- recorded all that was there but after listening to my new intro a lot it’s bought a new perspective. Kick will change and claps will go. The acid will go but the main lead will stay and bassline might have slightly different fx.

Loving the atmosphere in the intro
https://soundcloud.com/robert-george-969154201%2Ftrancefix-st-dv-n-smma-s3wve%2Fs-WcFzq77jpgz
 
Last edited:
  • Thanks
Reactions: Recharge

Recharge

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 26, 2020
Messages
838
Thanked
413
Age
37
I really love this version. It screams 90s and in a good way, no scratch that, in a great way.

I also like the previous version, its more beefy, but this one has such a great chill vibe.
 
  • Thanks
Reactions: Bobby Summa