Spotify automix function

Ar7

Member
Jan 4, 2022
35 Posts
40 Thanked
I’ve recently stumbled upon what seems a renewed automix function in Spotify. It works remarkably well! I have a playlist with classic trance tracks and it mixes these 7-9 minute tracks to a very good continuous mix.

What are you experiences with it?
 

Ar7

Member
Jan 4, 2022
35 Posts
40 Thanked
I completely agree that when looking from the perspective of the entire industry it is probably a net negative. But it is a rare case when within my personal experience AI has given something positive. I don’t have access to classic compilation and this function means that my collection of favourite tracks coalesce around something resembling a single listening experience:)
 

Magdelayna

Elite Member
Jul 13, 2020
2,359 Posts
2,188 Thanked
West Yorkshire,England
Website
soundcloud.com
I completely agree that when looking from the perspective of the entire industry it is probably a net negative. But it is a rare case when within my personal experience AI has given something positive. I don’t have access to classic compilation and this function means that my collection of favourite tracks coalesce around something resembling a single listening experience:)

I agree,its great for a casual listener who wants to compile all their faves into one mix. Great for this 'instant' gratification generation haha.
 

Julian Del Agranda

Elite Member
Jul 3, 2020
2,247 Posts
2,993 Thanked
It works amazingly bad. How can you say it works good?

It's beatmatched, but that's all it does. The transitions are aweful. It fades in a vocal (so it's mid-sentence) on top of melodies that fade out. It sucks.

For home parties... yeah it could be OK. The only plus side of this system is.... the system plays tracks for 1-2 minutes, not whole tracks. So that's a good quality for a home party. The 'deejaying', if a DJ did this at a wedding, I would point and laugh at him and tell him to go home. It sucks.

Edit: I have heard like 5 transitions now... and the beatmatching is also quite poor. So the grid-detection they use... doesn't do it's job well.

To be honest: Spotify has a little fade in / fade out function, where you can "mix" tracks a few seconds. I find that function working a lot better if you put that on like 2 seconds (for radio edit tracks).
 
Last edited:

Ar7

Member
Jan 4, 2022
35 Posts
40 Thanked
Learn to mix instead? Its not that hard - and gives much more satisfaction...software programs like Mixmeister.
This isn’t a very rational argument that completely misunderstands what is instant gratification. We have to differentiate between using a technology/tool/etc as a utility or to chase a quick dopamine hit.

It’s like saying that if you grill meat, but you didn’t go hunting or if you take a cab instead of driving then it is instant gratification.

Not every person has to learn every skill. I have other pursuits that give me more satisfaction and I chose not to learn mixing. So using automix is a utility and has nothing to do with instant gratification.
 
  • Thanks
Reactions: Hensmon and Jetflag

Ar7

Member
Jan 4, 2022
35 Posts
40 Thanked
It works amazingly bad. How can you say it works good?

It's beatmatched, but that's all it does. The transitions are aweful. It fades in a vocal (so it's mid-sentence) on top of melodies that fade out. It sucks.

For home parties... yeah it could be OK. The only plus side of this system is.... the system plays tracks for 1-2 minutes, not whole tracks. So that's a good quality for a home party. The 'deejaying', if a DJ did this at a wedding, I would point and laugh at him and tell him to go home. It sucks.

Edit: I have heard like 5 transitions now... and the beatmatching is also quite poor. So the grid-detection they use... doesn't do it's job well.

To be honest: Spotify has a little fade in / fade out function, where you can "mix" tracks a few seconds. I find that function working a lot better if you put that on like 2 seconds (for radio edit tracks).
I will rephrase, it is good compared to the effort required. Of course it is nothing compared to a talented dj:)
 

Electronlyman

Senior Member
Jul 14, 2020
912 Posts
724 Thanked
Automix?

Check out the new mix function that's now available in your playlists!

Manual beatmatching is now possible.

Now that's more like it!
 
Last edited:
  • Thanks
Reactions: Ar7

Electronlyman

Senior Member
Jul 14, 2020
912 Posts
724 Thanked


I mixed my Oliver Lieb Playlist using
the new Mix function (Beta).
(Not automix!)

Not sure if it only works on Premium
- please let me know if you hear the playlist mixed or non mixed

So far not bad !
Doesn't allow live mixing, but it would suffice for making a mixed set for a home party.
I managed to create some decent transitions.

There's significantly more control compared to the automix function.

It allows you to align tracks manually, use multiple volume, bassline, Freq transition envelopes. The transitions are limited to 16 bars max.

Update:

I've experienced some of the transitions had time shifted upon listening to the whole mix and sound a bit off. When I open the editing view they are correct again .. Let's see if it still happens on my second listen.
 
Last edited:

Electronlyman

Senior Member
Jul 14, 2020
912 Posts
724 Thanked
This is how the description looks, when the playlist has been mixed with the new mixing option.

Screenshot_2025-10-12-12-37-56-242_com.spotify.music-edit.jpg
 

Jetflag

Legendary Member
Jul 17, 2020
4,744 Posts
4,183 Thanked
This isn’t a very rational argument that completely misunderstands what is instant gratification. We have to differentiate between using a technology/tool/etc as a utility or to chase a quick dopamine hit.

It’s like saying that if you grill meat, but you didn’t go hunting or if you take a cab instead of driving then it is instant gratification.

Not every person has to learn every skill. I have other pursuits that give me more satisfaction and I chose not to learn mixing. So using automix is a utility and has nothing to do with instant gratification.
Agree with this statement, ai is fine as a tool.

and there is absolutely no need to apologise for it towards people trying to guilt trip you for using it over their respective hobby being under threat.
 
  • Thanks
Reactions: Ar7

Magdelayna

Elite Member
Jul 13, 2020
2,359 Posts
2,188 Thanked
West Yorkshire,England
Website
soundcloud.com
Agree with this statement, ai is fine as a tool.

and there is absolutely no need to apologise for it towards people trying to guilt trip you for using it over their respective hobby being under threat.

Nah,it just breeds more of this instant,press one button and youre done generation - its all going down the pan imo. The mixes section will be full of Spotify AI mixes soon...
 

Jetflag

Legendary Member
Jul 17, 2020
4,744 Posts
4,183 Thanked
Nah,it just breeds more of this instant,press one button and youre done generation - its all going down the pan imo. The mixes section will be full of Spotify AI mixes soon...
..And no amount of spiteful sabot sticking or complaining is going to alter that Adam. Your best bet is to encourage tool-based behaviour v full-front-end use..and ofcourse supporting “human” artists.

but Ai is here to stay, like it or not 🤷‍♂️
 
Last edited:

Magdelayna

Elite Member
Jul 13, 2020
2,359 Posts
2,188 Thanked
West Yorkshire,England
Website
soundcloud.com
..And no amount of spiteful sabot sticking or complaining is going to alter that Adam. Your best bet is to encourage tool-based behaviour v full-front-end use..and ofcourse supporting “human” artists.

but Ai is here to stay, like it or not 🤷‍♂️

Oh,i know its staying,and all going downhill year by year now - il just keep on what ive been doing,im just glad i have a true, genuine following that ive built up over the years. Its just painful to see what the industry is becoming..
 
  • Thanks
Reactions: Jetflag

Jetflag

Legendary Member
Jul 17, 2020
4,744 Posts
4,183 Thanked
Oh,i know its staying,and all going downhill year by year now - il just keep on what ive been doing,im just glad i have a true, genuine following that ive built up over the years. Its just painful to see what the industry is becoming..
same here, and I actually count myself as one of your followers m8 🤷‍♂️ but i'm equally of the stance that telling other people what to do with their free time is pointless if not downright counter-productive. At best you can sort of friendly-hint to the benefits of doing it yourself.

Its a bit like the whole guilt-tripping people for mixing cdj's or mp3's instead of vinyl we had back in the days or the whole "complain for alleged education's sake " phenomenon i often see in the new releases section.

its not actually going to stem to the tide in reverse or convince producers to go and make stuff that more adheres to said posters specific "good trance" taste... In fact in case of the latter they're far more likely to go somewhere else with a bit more positive encouragement.

I think in the end what we do will be akin to say: one man business custom knife sculpting. Where smithing as a craft used to be the standard. The overwhealming majority of cultery is shlop from an ikea factory nowadays, but you still have small hobbyist communities who do it for the fun of making things. :), not to please "teh mainstream audience" so to put it.

and i'm actually fine with that.. in 30 years it'll be granddad's cringe or mindly interresting hobby. 😋
 
  • Thanks
Reactions: Ar7 and LostLegend