Ok so
@Archon I finished True Detectives last night. I really really want to give it legendary status, a 90/100, and probably will, but something niggling at me, because the ending is a bit of underwhelming compared to what it could have been. It's not bad by any means, but I have issues, and I don't think it delivers on the build up it created.
Do you remember it well? That final marco-polo type chase in the underground tunnels is a little cheesy/lame. Not that tense or interesting, especially when you think back to the scene where Rust robs the drug dealers with the bike gang. That actually had my heart going.
There was also so much build up to this "Yellow King" character, but is he that memorable? Not really imposing, maybe could have been cast and written better? Dewall Ledoux was more imposing.
They also just bowl up to this man's house without any strategy or caution. When they tracked down Ledouxs place in ep 4 they sneak into the perimeter, avoid traps and tactically engage, which makes perfect sense. Given the stakes here it seemed incredible lazy/uncharacteristic to just roll in, knock on the front door, and hope for the best.
The plot also turns out to be quite a straight forward crime mystery in the end. A lot threads don't go anywhere - arguably realistic in how crime works, but not narratively satisfying for a viewer - and it's solved in too easy sherlockian kind of way, where they put together tax records, housing records, and figure out the paint color of a house etc. Not that clever or interesting ultimately.
It doesn't pay off on all the themes it establishes too. It implies and presents this larger darkness, with all this occultism and lovecraftian like cosmic horror, but never delivers on that. There was meant to be this big conspiracy and mystic force behind it all, but essentially we get a weirdo in his wood hut who enjoys diddling his sister, and not much else. Not really clear how he fits in to the bigger picture and why he's that 'special' anyway.
Still love the show, but it does fumble the ending somewhat, although I personally love Rust's NDE experience how he begins to replace nihilism with optimism. Dude neeeded to catch a break badly.