- Jul 1, 2020
- 882 Posts
- 581 Thanked
OUT THE3 ONE - Berlin [Vandit]
- Thread starter skyriderz
- Start date
Enlusion
Senior Member
1024th attempt to copy For An Angel, same melodic rhythm just changed notes.
- Jul 1, 2020
- 882 Posts
- 581 Thanked
Well the first three chords reminds of for an Angel, rest is far away from that. Seems this producer Idol is PvD.
Jetflag
Elite Member
- Jul 17, 2020
- 2,770 Posts
- 2,200 Thanked
Everything about this, the whole setup, soundpallet, Cadance etc is just For an Angel on 2022 Ableton.
Its good technically/production wise..But I think it would have been a hell of a lot less creatively bankrupt if Th3 One just did an honest, tribute remix of "For an angel" instead of mouse-moving a few midi notes and labeling it: "an original track"
I have absolutely no problem is someone wants to bring tribute to an iconic and loved sound like say: D1mension did with Origami, but this? this is just lazy hubris in my opinion.
If PVD is your idol and you want to bring tribute to one if his most iconic tracks, fine. Do an honest remix and call it that
Paul van Dyk - For an Angel (Th3 One remix)
Its good technically/production wise..But I think it would have been a hell of a lot less creatively bankrupt if Th3 One just did an honest, tribute remix of "For an angel" instead of mouse-moving a few midi notes and labeling it: "an original track"
I have absolutely no problem is someone wants to bring tribute to an iconic and loved sound like say: D1mension did with Origami, but this? this is just lazy hubris in my opinion.
If PVD is your idol and you want to bring tribute to one if his most iconic tracks, fine. Do an honest remix and call it that
Paul van Dyk - For an Angel (Th3 One remix)
Definitely sounds like PVD tribute track and a remix for For An Angel indeed. BUT in a rather amateurish way. I would not say its garbage, just a a tribute track from a bedroom producer...nothing wrong with that, I would just not release such track on Vandit