qoob - The Four Stages Of Man [Pure Progressive]

Artist(s)
qoob
Release title
The Four Stages Of Man
Label name
Pure Progressive
Release date
Feb 24, 2023
Release type
Single
Link to external store
https://www.beatport.com/release/the-four-stages-of-man/4002992

Archon

Gagi
Mod
Jun 27, 2020
4,426 Posts
3,388 Thanked
It sounds very very good, however I feel like it's missing a section. Would like to see it progress somewhere, have some melodic moments.
 
  • Thanks
Reactions: Pokkryshkin

Spacetime

Senior Member
Nov 6, 2021
292 Posts
218 Thanked
Bullshit this is empty. It sounds great. Youre trying to compare it with some breeder 02 stuff, it's not trying to be that. There are other approaches to progressive that are still valid and have value.
 

Daysleeper

Lost in Trancelation
Jul 13, 2020
2,814 Posts
2,078 Thanked
Sweden
Its pretty boring. Its too subtle/ too static,too slow,musically/rhythmically uninteresting/dull. It basically only sounds good aurally/sonically. It has a bit of build/texture but it just doesnt evolve into anything more than a background elevator slow-pace proghouse number.

Its not entirley because its in this imo uncomfortable"feel-very-slow-zone" which is 120-128bpm I dislike these tunes, but its the productionstyle and way of building the tracks, theres so little emphasis on good arrangement and building momentum. Its basically just one beat running along the whole track, with some small subtle sound changes/fx running on top. Ive seen this stuff since the early 2010 as some sort of anti-movement on steroid trance, but it doesnt work, because it just does what steroid trance does but on the other side of the spectrum so to say. I rather listen to some dub- techno or ambient that is even more minimal than this but still somehow more musically intriguing.
 

Pokkryshkin

Senior Member
May 7, 2022
831 Posts
605 Thanked
On the contrary, I like trance more calm, slow and measured. Although this is not a trance but a progressive house of the old school. Someone wrote that this is a modern progressive, this is not so.
 

TwinSilo

Senior Member
Feb 24, 2021
468 Posts
310 Thanked
USA
Not outstanding but will give it more tries. Some parts are nice. I didn't like the Luke Chable track from last year initially for some of the reasons mentioned above, but in the end really loved it.
 

Sean Cong

Member
Jan 12, 2023
162 Posts
210 Thanked
Beijing, China
This is THE most listened track of mine in the entire year of 2023. Excellent and outstanding. It deserves a 9/10 for me.

When I heard it for the first time in Forerunners' Pure Prog Vol. 2, I loved it instantly because of its sound design. When this track finally got released, I got impressed even further.

Instead of pointless sfx in other tracks that make them hollow and empty, this track is steadily and constantly progressing, morphing its shape into various forms. It is neither minimal nor empty, but an astonishing example of how a slow progressive track can exhibit its maximalist beauty -- it keeps building higher and higher, with multiple elements saturating and resonating, creating a coherent masterpiece. The pulsing rhythm also fits well for early-stage warmups, driving us to move our bodies.
(No, this is not an AI-generated comment. These are all my personal thoughts)

It is indeed not that melodic, but its progression simply touches me in my heart. If you need a more melodic one, I think "qoob - Sun's Horses" is another outstanding one with clearer melodies. But for me, the latter one resembles "The Four Stages Of Man" too much, and sounds less steady. So I still prefer this one.

Out of the 3 volumes of Pure Progressive, I like Vol. 2 the best.
And out of the entire Vol. 2, I like this track the best.
(As for Vol. 3, I prefer "Gundamea - Flares" and "Narel - What Your Cause Will Be". And for Vol. 1, I prefer "Deepsky - Cosmic Dancer (Orkidea Pure Progressive Remix)")

I'm pretty surprised that the posts here are mostly neutral or negative here, given the fact that there are a group of trance lovers (including myself) in China all commenting about how brilliant this track is.
 
Last edited:

Hensmon

Admin
Mod
Jun 27, 2020
4,328 Posts
4,300 Thanked
UK
I did end up picking this one up when it released and added to the Ipod. As more listens got stacked I started liking it more and more. Thanks for the bump.
 
  • Thanks
Reactions: Sean Cong

SaltAcidFatHeatAcid

Senior Member
Jul 19, 2022
657 Posts
890 Thanked
I did end up picking this one up when it released and added to the Ipod. As more listens got stacked I started liking it more and more. Thanks for the bump.

Yeah, I don't get the criticism for this one. For modern styled prog I don't find this one lacking at all. It's not the journey styled prog of old, but neither are our attention spans matched to that style anymore either lol.
 
  • Thanks
Reactions: Sean Cong